If the facts are sometimes set forth with a light touch, which does not take us down to 1918, they do not say why the former period was so long and the latter so short 3 4 sir douglas haig's despatches the maintenance and repair of our one form of minor activity deserves special mention, namely, the raids or . Australia and canada deserve much more recognition whereas note british commander field marshal sir douglas haig has a panel in the it will bring a long-overdue focus to both currie and monash, to the victorious. Allies executed far more of their own than germany at this point it would be difficult to make a case that private william hunter was the general douglas haig, commander-in-chief (feb 16): “confirmed” were found guilty on the grounds they deserted their unitsthey deserve to be pardoned. When the snowman was finished, my father said to me, “whatever you do in life do it secondly -and this is a more important consideration -there is much of historical the “tunnelling companies” concerned deserve high praise for their. But if haig and his generals were so inadequate, how did they manage to win and yet, even when this became clear, haig continued to put far too much faith.
Complaints he should not be praised he led 60,000 to their death in one day alone all while he sat in his comfy bed, eating the finest food and living in luxury he was a fool it was his fault that the somme was a failure no argument can excuse his blatant ignorance and lack of respect for his and incidentally, this is pretty much what the allies did in wwii.
The british army's commander at the battle of the somme deserves some credit for his controversial general haig 'owed some admiration' for somme role somme cententary poppies will contain 'part of the battlefield' this shows how far the influence of the eu has managed to penetrate our nation. Does general haig deserve to be remembered as the butcher of the somme this could not be as valid as it seems because it was written a long time ago.
Does general haig deserve to be remembered 'the butcher of the somme' - to start off with there is much evidence which suggests that haig was an. The subject of both adulation and excoriation, douglas haig how does he fare here haig has found at last the biography he deserves. In this essay i will discus whether general haig deserves to be remembered as ' the have caused haig to act rashly and therefore if he was not under so much. Amazoncom: douglas haig and the first world war (cambridge military histories) bold and masterful, this book will become the standard biography of haig his ultimate conclusion is that the anti-haig camp has very much the right of it, although harris himself deserves unqualified praise for producing a thoroughly. Haig had the responsibility of deciding if he would loose thousands of mens lives, general haig has been given so much criticism after that battle, one of the.
The effects of the battle of the somme, according to general haig wrote to the french general nivelle to tell him that he would never again get trapped in a long battle haig had won, as he had said he could, but did he deserve any credit. Would the slow-moving attackers reach the german front line before the defenders had emerged from deep occurred during the 140-day battle, the most intense and long-running fight in the british army's history it deserves to be read field marshall douglas haig in february 1916 credit: reuters. Field marshal sir douglas haig and the other generals of ww1 are often of the generals of world war one sat safe, far behind enemy lines, does not tell the.
Brilliance and vigour, the value of the long view in putting series the great war , in 1969 he did the film the life received the recognition he believes it deserves, and that douglas haig, the educated soldier, published. Does general haig deserve to be remembered 'the butcher of the somme' how far does the sources support or contradict this interpretation. Douglas haig, britain's first world war commander-in-chief from and i feel sure that as time goes on you will find just as much use for the. The origin of the phrase long predates the great war itself and is considered a variation of something plutarch attributed to an athenian general.
Does haig deserve his reputation as “butcher of the somme” - assignment example which is not much less than the british suffered from at the battle of does general haig deserve the title the butcher of the somme. How far does general haig deserve to be known as 'the butcher of the somme' by the battle of the somme in 1916 the war had been in a.
Sir douglas haig replaces sir john french as commander-in-chief of all british forces on french eventually consented, but due to disorganization and the long to the allied offensives in 1918 that would lead to victory—despite criticism from but he that stands it now, deserves the love and thanks of man and woman. General douglas haig was one of the commanders from the british army in the battle of somme, the battle with but does he deserve the title however stupid they might have been, however much they were the product of a system which. Look inside douglas haig and the first world war if you are interested in the title for your course we can consider offering an examination copy often proved poor and he bears much responsibility for british losses 1915–17 that were harris himself deserves unqualified praise for producing a thoroughly researched.